From ‘No’ to ‘Oh No!’: 35+ Actors Who Passed On Legendary Film Roles and Regretted It

Hollywood’s history is sprinkled with tales of ‘what could have been.’ Imagine a world where Harrison Ford wasn’t piloting the Millennium Falcon or where the legendary Jack Dawson wasn’t portrayed by Leonardo DiCaprio. Sounds off-kilter, right? While we’ve come to love and cherish certain film characters precisely because of the stars who portrayed them, it’s astounding to realize how many of these roles were initially turned down by others.

The reasons? Everything from packed calendars to personal tiffs or even an indifferent shrug towards the script. Dive into these captivating tales of missed opportunities and discover the iconic movie moments that could have looked remarkably different with another face on the screen.

This article was originally published on absolutelyconnected.com and has been republished here with permission.

Emma Roberts Said No To Harley Quinn

Australian actress Margot Robbie’s outstanding performance in The Wolf of Wall Street caused her to become a household name. When she was cast as Harley Quinn, comic book fans went nuts because they finally had a wonderful new rendition of the Joker’s wacky sidekick.

Isn’t it difficult to imagine anyone else except her? American Horror Story’s Emma Roberts, it turns out, was in the running to be the evil henchwoman. Instead, she chose to play Chanel Oberlin, the evil diva from the terrifying television program Scream Queens. We are trying hard to picture her saying “puddin’,” but it’s simply odd.

Will Smith Turned Down The Matrix

Actors resign from roles for various reasons. We believe that failing to grasp the concept of the story is a good excuse to pass on a film, and Will Smith seems to agree. How can you play a part if you don’t understand the plot’s essence?

Smith was considered for the role of Neo in The Matrix, which became a worldwide phenomenon. Although the film’s convoluted plot appears to be daunting at first, Keanu Reeves’ performance proves that it is feasible. Smith, on the other hand, has no regrets since he believes he was not the right fit for it.

Lindsay Lohan Almost Played Jade

Lindsay Lohan starred in Labor Pains, a film about labor pains, in an attempt to resurrect her sagging career in 2009. In a way, it worked and put her in the spotlight. But the issue is she tried her luck in The Hangover before committing to that subpar job.

Heather Graham was cast as Jade, the exotic dancer with a baby the gang befriends. Todd Phillips, the director, apparently thought Lindsay was too young for the part. Lindsay’s career plummeted along with Labor Pains, which earned a pitiful $1.8 million. Things may have turned out quite differently for her.

Jim Carrey Almost Played Captain Jack Sparrow

Canadian actor Jim Carrey has established himself as one of Hollywood’s best and most popular actors thanks to his comedic chops and excellent acting abilities. He has won our hearts in a number of famous films, but did you know he was almost cast as Captain Jack Sparrow?

It is difficult to imagine anyone other than Johnny Depp as the wacky pirate captain in the Pirates of the Caribbean trilogy. Despite this, Jim Carrey was approached for the position but turned it down due to scheduling difficulties with Bruce Almighty. We wonder what his Jack Sparrow would have been like!

Emma Watson Missed Out On La La Land

The likeness between these two actresses is uncanny at times, so it’s no surprise that they might have swapped parts in an instant. Emma Watson, the well-known British actress, came dangerously close to stealing an Oscar-winning part from another Emma.

American actress Emma Stone sang and danced her way to an Oscar win in La La Land. Emma Watson, on the other hand, spent most of the production working alongside a man dressed in a CGI outfit. The box office success of Beauty and the Beast begs the question: how does a Disney remake stack up against an original story?

Charlie Hunnam Almost Played Christian Grey

The 50 Shades of Grey book series, which began as little more than Twilight fan fiction, swept into our lives and never left. Their quality is disputed, but their success is undeniable. That’s why, when the casting for the films began, we knew the actor who would play Christian Grey would be instantly famous.

British actor Charlie Hunnam was the frontrunner for the role of the enigmatic businessman, but Jamie Dornan was chosen instead. Hunnam said he passed due to scheduling difficulties with Sons of Anarchy, but he has no regrets. Is he aware of the budgets for the films?

Julia Roberts Said No To The Blind Side

Julia Roberts is the queen of rom-coms, having starred in a number of them and even receiving an Oscar for her part in Erin Brockovich. She’s still a fantastic actor, but it appears that she prefers light-hearted films these days, and we rarely see her in dramatic roles.

Knowing the type of role she passed up to star in Valentine’s Day, a critically panned film, makes us feel sad for her. In fact, Sandra Bullock, who was nominated for an Academy Award for her critically lauded performance in The Blind Side, was almost cast in the film instead of Roberts.

Nicolas Cage’s Almost Played Aragorn

Nicholas Cage in The Lord of the Rings is next on the list of things we never thought possible. Cage was reportedly considered for the role of Aragorn in the fantasy epic. But what went wrong, and what went right?

It was most likely due to schedule issues. He claims he has no regrets and that he still enjoys seeing the movies today. He did agree that if he had pursued it, it could have helped his career very much. We would say he’s correct, given that he did Captain Corelli’s Mandolin instead, which wasn’t exactly a box-office smash.

Sandra Bullock Turned Down Million Dollar Baby

The original Miss Congeniality picture was a big hit. That’s why it’s no surprise that Sandra Bullock, the film’s leading woman, agreed to reprise her role in the sequel. So far, everything has gone well.

Unfortunately, her decision to pursue Miss Congeniality 2 cost her an amazing role in Million Dollar Baby. Hilary Swank, who won the Academy Award for Best Actress, was cast in the role. Bullock revealed that she attempted to produce the picture herself but that once it began production, she was unable to do so owing to prior commitments. The importance of timing cannot be overstated.

Stanley Kubrick’s First Choice Didn’t Cut It

Over the years, the late and great Robin Williams played many fascinating characters. Like everyone else, he’s made good and bad decisions, but it’s not always up to the actor. When it came to casting Jack in The Shining, Stanley Kubrick’s initial option was Williams.

Stephen King (the author of the novel on which the picture is based) didn’t approve of the idea, as he was mostly a comic at the time. Williams went on to play Popeye instead, and only later in his career did he take on more dramatic roles. After casting Jack Nicholson, the rest is history.

Rachel McAdams Almost Starred In The Devil Wears Prada

Rachel McAdams had a big year back in 2004 when both Mean Girls and The Notebook became international hits. Understandably, the actress became overwhelmed by it all and opted to take on smaller roles for a brief period. She was supposedly “determined not to do it” when she was asked to play Andy in The Devil Wears Prada.

The film was a box office success, and Anne Hathaway landed the role of her dreams despite the fact that she had to fight for the part of the unfashionable secretary. McAdams moved on to Wedding Crashers before returning to starring roles.

Al Pacino Almost Played Han Solo

Al Pacino has established himself as a great icon in the world of gangster cinema, but not just that. He’s an Oscar winner with a long list of notable roles, but there is one that he let pass. We are curious what his career would have been like if he had been cast in Star Wars, as he almost was.

Is there anyone else who could portray Han Solo, the beloved smuggler and commander of the Millennium Falcon, besides Harrison Ford? Instead, Pacino chose Bobby Deerfield, and we haven’t been able to think straight since learning of his career-altering decision.

Tiffany Haddish Turned Down Get Out

American comic and actress Tiffany Haddish was able to break into the Hollywood scene and conquer it. Jordan Peele approached her after she had a few good roles under her belt and asked her to join Get Out. We are still baffled as to why she declined.

Peele’s directorial debut was a huge success, earning him an Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay in 2018. Haddish stated that she did not want to make horror films and chose a lighter role in Girls Trip as a result. American movie and theater Betty Gabriel ended up being cast in part.

Hugh Jackman Almost Played James Bond

Who could refuse the supreme chance to play James Bond? The character has been around since 1962, and many actors have lined up to play the legendary spy. However, not all actors have the same criteria when choosing roles.

Hugh Jackman received a crucial call just as filming for X-Men 2 was about to begin. He was offered the role of Bond but turned it down because the franchise had become too “unbelievable and insane” for him. Although his reputation blew up because of his portrayal of Wolverine, watching him as the elegant spy would have been fantastic.

Christina Applegate Missed Out On Legally Blonde

When Christina Applegate played Kelly Bundy on Married With Children, she was a natural at playing the naïve blonde. Her career was still developing at the time, but she was on the verge of landing a job that would have catapulted her to superstardom.

Applegate was offered the lead role of Elle Woods in Legally Blonde while the film was still in pre-production. She reportedly declined because she did not want to be known as the “dumb blonde” any longer. Reese Witherspoon crushed that performance and went on to star and produce Legally Blonde 2, which also proved very successful.

Anthony Mackie Wanted to Be Black Panther

Before Chadwick Boseman immortalized the role of Black Panther, Anthony Mackie was among the actors considered for the iconic Marvel superhero. Mackie, known for his role as Falcon in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, had expressed interest in bringing T’Challa to life on the big screen.

The idea of Mackie as the ruler of Wakanda intrigued fans and filmmakers alike. However, the casting ultimately favored Boseman, whose portrayal brought depth, dignity, and a lasting legacy to the character. While Mackie continued to soar as Falcon, the possibility of him as Black Panther remains an interesting “what if” in Marvel casting history.

Iwan Rheon Was Almost Jon Snow

Before Kit Harington became the face of Jon Snow, one of the most pivotal characters in “Game of Thrones,” Iwan Rheon was a strong contender for the role. Rheon, later known for his chilling portrayal of Ramsay Bolton in the series, initially auditioned for the part of the brooding Lord Commander of the Night’s Watch.

The casting process was highly competitive, with Rheon’s talent making him a close second for the role. Imagining Rheon as Jon Snow presents an intriguing alternate universe for fans. However, his eventual casting as Ramsay Bolton allowed him to leave an indelible mark on the series, showcasing his versatility and skill as an actor in one of television’s most memorable villainous roles.

Michael B. Jordan Said No To Straight Outta Compton

Michael B. Jordan has become a household name in the film industry in recent years. The actor has achieved international acclaim for his roles in blockbusters such as Creed and Black Panther. Unfortunately, success does not exempt you from making poor decisions on occasion.

Two significant films were released in 2015. One was a box office success, while the other was a flop. Jordan made the incorrect decision when he was requested to star in Straight Outta Compton, which was a huge success by Dr. Dre himself. Michael went on to direct Fantastic Four, which was a box office disaster.

Leonardo DiCaprio Passed Up Spider-Man

Could we picture the Oscar-winning actor Leonardo DiCaprio swinging between New York City skyscrapers as our friendly neighborhood Spider-Man in an alternate Hollywood universe? Surprisingly, it could have been a reality! Leo, who enthralled audiences with his impeccable performances in Titanic and The Revenant, was a front-runner for Peter Parker’s role in the Spider-Man franchise, according to rumors, since he never agreed to approve it.

Can you imagine DiCaprio, instead of Tobey Maguire, delivering the iconic line, “With great power, comes great responsibility”? However, Leo opted to turn down the opportunity to don the Spider-Man suit, choosing instead to focus on more character-driven roles. And while his career has certainly been stellar, part of him might regret not being part of a franchise that revolutionized the superhero genre.

Emily Browning Turned Down The Role Of Bella Swan

Emily Browning is probably unknown to you because of a decision she made in 2009. When this young actress was offered the role of Bella in a vampire film, she found herself in a dilemma. Instead of Twilight, she chose The Uninvited, an unknown horror film. It was Stephenie Meyer who wanted her to play Bella.

Browning squandered a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. Kristen Stewart is a well-known actress who has progressed from her role as Bella to that of a respected actor. It’s impossible to say where Browning’s career might be now if she had agreed to play the pasty vampire.

Cameron Diaz Passed On The Devil Wears Prada

The 2006 hit, “The Devil Wears Prada,” is often heralded as a modern classic, offering a satirical glimpse into the high-pressure world of fashion through the lens of a ruthless editor-in-chief, Miranda Priestly, impeccably portrayed by Meryl Streep. However, before Streep stepped into the high heels of the fashion mogul, Cameron Diaz was in talks for the role. Diaz, known for her comedic touch and effortless charm, was seen as a potential fit for the role. However, the stars didn’t align for her to don Miranda’s crisp, designer outfits and icy demeanor.

When the role was eventually passed to Meryl Streep, it elevated the movie to cult status and left an indelible mark on Streep’s illustrious career. As the film garnered accolades and Streep received praises for a role seemingly tailor-made for her, Diaz could only watch from the sidelines, contemplating the ‘runway’ that got away. Although Diaz has never publicly expressed regret over missing out on the role, it’s one of those Hollywood what-ifs that continue to enthrall audiences and remind actors of the fine line between rejection and legendary status.

Thomas Brodie-Sangster Was In The Running For Ron Weasley

The whims of casting almost saw Thomas Brodie-Sangster of “Love Actually” fame as Ron Weasley in the “Harry Potter” series, a role eventually secured by Rupert Grint. At age 10, Brodie-Sangster auditioned for the 2001 film “Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone” but faced rejection, a bitter first in his budding career.

Lady Gaga as Phoebe Buffay

Imagine the iconic Phoebe Buffay from “Friends”, known for her whimsical, quirky nature, being portrayed by Lady Gaga, a symbol of creativity and expressiveness. Phoebe’s traits like her child-like naïveté, musical talent, and tendency to be a loner, would have found a unique resonance with Gaga’s own attributes. Gaga’s passion, resilience, and her journey towards self-acceptance would have added depth to Phoebe’s simplistic, non-conformist approach to life​​​​​​​​.

Saoirse Ronan Tried Out For The Role Of Luna Lovegood

Before rising to stardom through roles in “The Lovely Bones” and “Hanna”, Irish actress Saoirse Ronan, at the age of 13, auditioned for the role of Luna Lovegood in the Harry Potter franchise, a part that eventually went to Evanna Lynch​. The role, beginning from the fifth film, “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix”, and spanning to the end of the series, could have marked a significant chapter in Ronan’s early acting career, potentially earning her a spot in four of the Harry Potter films​.

Dwayne Johnson as Thor

While Chris Hemsworth has become synonymous with Thor, wielding Mjolnir with a commanding presence, there was a time when fans speculated about the possibility of Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson taking on the role. Johnson, with his towering physique and charismatic aura, seemed a fitting choice to portray the God of Thunder.

Imaginations ran wild with the thought of him bringing a different flavor to the Asgardian hero. Though it remained speculation, the idea of Johnson’s take on the character intrigues many, pondering how his unique blend of intensity and humor could have electrified the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

Sandra Bullock as Cruella de Vil

The thought of Sandra Bullock portraying Cruella de Vil teases a fascinating twist on the character immortalized by Glenn Close. Bullock, with her flair for portraying nuanced characters, could have offered a Cruella that balanced Close’s dramatic poise with a distinct edge.

While the mantle was ultimately passed to Emma Stone for a younger iteration of the character, the notion of Bullock as the fur-obsessed villain remains a tantalizing ‘what could have been,’ hinting at a portrayal that might have woven sophistication, humor, and a touch of darkness into the fabric of this timeless antagonist.

Indiana Jones Was Almost Played By Tom Selleck

There are some movie characters that are so beloved by the audience that they get very protective of them. Isn’t Indiana Jones incomplete without Harrison Ford?
Selleck, the star of the 80s television show Magnum P.I., came in to do a screen test for Indiana Jones.

After his screen test, the filmmakers offered him the part, per Classic Country Music. He rejected it due to existing Magnum commitments. He had no idea that by denying Indiana Jones, he would be foregoing the opportunity to star in an international and multigenerational fan-favorite franchise, but he seemed to have no regrets.

Saoirse Ronan Almost Became The Scarlet Witch

Movies about superheroes were not always as popular as they are now. However, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has changed all of that, and today, rather than productions pursuing stars, actors are pursuing roles in Marvel or DC films. It is no surprise, then, that Saoirse Ronan was considered for the role of Wanda in The Avengers 2: Age of Ultron.

Elizabeth Olsen was subsequently cast in the part, and Saoirse featured in Brooklyn, earning her another Oscar nomination. Saoirse does not rule out joining the MCU in the future after the success of Brooklyn. We think it’s a win-win situation.

The Barbie Role Amy Schumer Left Behind

Initially cast as Barbie, comedian Amy Schumer excitedly joined the project before stepping away a year later. While “scheduling conflicts” were initially cited, Schumer later revealed her real reason: creative differences. She envisioned a Barbie who was an “inventor,” conflicting with the studio’s less ambitious idea of a gelatin-crafted shoe.

In the end, Margot Robbie filled Schumer’s shoes—no pun intended—and the film went on to break records. Although she left the role, Schumer expressed satisfaction with the final product’s feminist leanings. Her departure remains one of Hollywood’s interesting “what ifs,” offering a glimpse into how casting changes can dramatically shape a film.

John Krasinski: The Captain America That Almost Was

John Krasinski, famed for his role as Jim Halpert on “The Office,” almost swapped his desk for Captain America’s shield. Known for later action roles in “Tom Clancy’s Jack Ryan” and “A Quiet Place,” Krasinski was a final contender for the coveted Marvel role. However, it was Chris Evans who ultimately snagged the part, becoming synonymous with the superhero.

While Evans’ portrayal is iconic, one can’t help but wonder how Krasinski’s unique blend of charm and action chops would have shaped Captain America and the Marvel Cinematic Universe as a whole. It remains one of Hollywood’s intriguing “what ifs,” adding a layer of allure to superhero cinema.

Ryan Gosling’s Near-Magical Encounter as Doctor Strange

Before Benedict Cumberbatch donned the Cloak of Levitation as Doctor Strange, Ryan Gosling was on Marvel’s radar for the magical role. Cumberbatch initially declined due to scheduling conflicts, prompting the studio to explore alternative actors. Gosling, known for his versatility, was a strong contender.

However, Marvel was so committed to Cumberbatch’s vision for the Sorcerer Supreme that they decided to delay filming to accommodate his schedule. The rest is cinematic history, as Cumberbatch’s portrayal became iconic. Yet, the thought of Gosling stepping into the mystical realm adds an intriguing “what if” to Marvel lore, making us wonder what his take on Doctor Strange would have been like.

Helen McCrory’s Near-Stint as Bellatrix Lestrange

A renowned actress, Helen McCrory was once set to bewitch audiences as the dark and malevolent Bellatrix Lestrange in the Harry Potter franchise. McCrory had landed the coveted role, a perfect opportunity to showcase her range and captivate fans of the series. However, life had different plans for her—she found out she was expecting a child. The timing of her pregnancy meant she couldn’t fully commit to the rigorous shooting schedule and physically demanding scenes the role required.

As a result, she had to bow out, leading the way for Helena Bonham Carter to step in and make the character her own. It’s fascinating to consider how McCrory’s interpretation of Bellatrix might have shifted the dynamics of the series, and the “what could have been” adds an extra layer of intrigue to the Harry Potter saga.

Tom Cruise’s Close Call With Marvel’s Iconic Role

Before Robert Downey Jr. immortalized Tony Stark, Tom Cruise was a top pick for the iconic Iron Man role. Cruise, known for his meticulous approach to filmmaking and performing his own stunts, was keen on having significant creative control over the project. However, he felt that the setup wasn’t aligning with his vision for making the film special.

Ultimately, he stepped back, paving the way for Downey to become the face of Tony Stark—a portrayal so definitive that even Cruise acknowledges it’s hard to imagine anyone else in the role. This makes Cruise’s decision one of Hollywood’s most intriguing “what ifs,” leaving us to wonder how he would have shaped the character and the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

Emily Blunt Missed Out On Black Widow

In extraordinary situations, actors wish to play a specific role but are unable to do so due to contractual obligations. Emily Blunt, who was slated to play Natasha Romanoff, a.k.a. Black Widow, in Iron Man 2, had the same fate.

The renowned Marvel character was not cast in a straightforward manner. Although Blunt was compelled to appear in Gulliver’s Travels, her heart belonged to Natasha. She couldn’t get out of doing the film, so Scarlett Johansson was cast instead. However, there isn’t much of a loss on the part of the audience since Scarlett did a magnificent job.

Kevin Costner Let The Shawshank Redemption Get Away

Imagine passing up a film that was a box office bomb in favor of one that grossed $264 million, but yet picking the wrong one. When popular American actor Kevin Costner signed up for Waterworld instead of The Shawshank Redemption, based on the 1982 Stephen King novel Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption.

The Shawshank Redemption may have been a box business flop, but it remains one of the best and highest-rated films of all time. However, Waterworld did well at the box office, but it does not change the fact that it is one of the worst films ever created.

Marilyn Monroe Turned Down Breakfast At Tiffany’s

Actresses who are just starting out need to be careful with their selections because your Hollywood image says a lot about you. That unstated rule was observed by American sensation Marilyn Monroe, who declined a legendary role in Breakfast at Tiffany’s.

While writing the story, loosely based on the novella by Truman Capote, the screenwriters reportedly had Monroe in mind, but her acting coach advised her to refuse. He believed that portraying Holly Golightly was detrimental to her reputation and that it was to Audrey Hepburn’s benefit. Monroe starred in her last movie, Misfits, which was released posthumously in 1962.

Conviction Over Cash: Chris Tucker’s Faith-Based Career Choices

Chris Tucker, renowned for his role as Smokey in “Friday,” turned down a $10-12 million offer for the sequel due to his Christian beliefs. He did not want to engage in on-screen behaviors like cursing or smoking weed, which conflicted with his faith.

Tucker became much more selective about his roles after becoming a born-again Christian, reportedly passing on parts in “Any Given Sunday” and “Lethal Weapon 4.” His commitment to his beliefs also led him to a different approach in stand-up comedy, avoiding raunchy material for deeper, clean humor​​.

Angelina Jolie’s Missed Angel

Angelina Jolie, a celebrated actress known for her versatility and powerful screen presence, has had her fair share of roles that she either turned down or missed out on. One notable instance is her decision not to star in “Charlie’s Angels.”

The film, which became a major hit, featured a dynamic trio of female leads, but Jolie chose to pursue other projects instead. This decision came during a period when Jolie was solidifying her status as a leading actress in Hollywood, often choosing roles that were complex and demanding.

Henry Cavill’s Missed

Henry Cavill, widely recognized for his portrayal of Superman in the DC Extended Universe, has had a fascinating journey with roles that he either passed on or narrowly missed.

<–add

Another noteworthy role that Cavill was considered for but did not secure was Edward Cullen in the “Twilight” saga. The role, which went to Robert Pattinson, became a cultural phenomenon and catapulted Pattinson to international fame. Cavill’s near-misses with such high-profile roles highlight the unpredictable nature of casting in Hollywood and the fine line between becoming a household name in one franchise versus another.

Matthew Broderick Almost Played Walter White

Movie stars are frequently given TV roles, and for some, the move from film to long-term television is difficult. At first, every offer seems like a gamble, but how naive do you have to be to turn down Walter White?

Breaking Bad, considered one of the greatest new classics, considered Matthew Broderick for the lead role. He was rumored to be working on other projects at the time, including 2008’s The Tales of Despereaux, an animated film about mice. Yes, he turned down Walter White in exchange for a sword-wielding mouse. It went to Malcolm in the Middle’s Bryan Cranston.

Leo DiCaprio Almost Starred In American Psycho

Leonardo DiCaprio is one of our generation’s most talented performers. He has retained his reputation as a great dramatic actor over the previous few decades. However, one of his less well-known parts is that of Richard in The Beach, which makes us question if he ever regrets not opting for American Psycho instead.

Leo was considered to play Patrick Bateman, but he chose to go with The Beach, a movie that performed poorly and went unnoticed. American Psycho may have made less money than The Beach, but it has stood the test of time, whereas The Beach certainly has not.

Michelle Pfeiffer Missed Out On The Silence Of The Lambs

Michelle Pfeiffer has a long history of memorable film roles. She was hesitant to take on the role of young and cautious police officer Clarice in The Silence of the Lambs when she was approached. Instead, she chose Frankie and Johnny, a lesser-known film with Al Pacino.

Jodie Foster eventually took on the role of the astute FBI agent. Pfeiffer was passed up for a role that would have earned Foster her second Oscar, but she explained that she declined because of the film’s premise. She said she was uncomfortable with how evil wins at the end of the movie.

Matt Damon Couldn’t Do Manchester By The Sea

Some scripts are simply too excellent to throw away. Matt Damon was almost cast as the director and lead of Manchester by the Sea, a 2016 dramatic film about grief and loss. However, Damon was already working on another movie, so he had to miss the performance that earned Casey Affleck an Oscar.

The film fared far better at the box office than Damon’s chosen sci-fi film, Downsizing. Manchester by the Sea was also regarded as one of the best films of the era. Damon kept involved in the film, though, becoming the producer, so it wasn’t a complete waste.

Brooke Shields Almost Starred As Elvira

One of the greatest cult classic gangster films was about to be released in 1983. Directed by Brian De Palma, it featured Al Pacino and Michelle Pfeiffer, who was a rising figure in Hollywood. She had appeared in a few films before, but Scarface is regarded as her breakthrough role. How difficult is it to envisage Brooke Shields in the role of Elvira instead?

Apparently, Brooke’s mother, Teri allegedly warned her against taking the part. Due to the violent nature of the picture, she believed it would be detrimental to her image. Unfortunately, she missed out on an incredible opportunity.

Bruce Willis Said No To Ghost

Would you take the chance to star beside your wife in one of the most romantic films ever created if the opportunity arose? Bruce Willis said “PASS” to a role in Ghost with his then-wife Demi Moore playing the love interest.

Willis didn’t believe the concept of a romantic relationship between a ghost and a living person could work, so he passed, and after seeing the end result, wishes he hadn’t. Ghost became a huge hit and gave Patrick Swayze one of his signature roles. Willis instead chose The Bonfires of the Vanities, a mediocre film released the same year.

Angela Bassett Turned Down Monster’s Ball

It is understandable why an actor would not want to play a character who does not appeal to them. If people find it offensive or humiliating, there may be no connection. Angela Bassett followed her heart, yet her choice cost her an Academy Award.

Bassett’s pick back then was The Score, which was well-received at the box office but is hardly recognized today. However, she could have portrayed Leticia in Halle Berry’s career-defining role in Monster’s Ball. Bassett thought the character’s affair in Monster’s Ball was “demeaning and clichéd”; therefore, she stuck to her principles despite losing a major role.

Michael Madsen Opted Out Of Pulp Fiction

Some consider Pulp Fiction to be Quentin Tarantino’s best film. Given the film’s major cultural significance, it is incredible that anyone could say no to such a masterpiece.

Vincent Vega, played by John Travolta, was offered to Michael Madsen. After working together on Reservoir Dogs, Madsen and Tarantino had a falling out when Madsen couldn’t do Pulp Fiction due to contractual obligations with Wyatt Earp. They eventually patched things up.

Tim Roth Almost Played Severus Snape

When Oscar-nominated actor Tim Roth joined Planet of the Apes in 2001, he thought he had made the correct decision.

The film grossed a respectable $362 million at the box office. He had no idea that another film he had passed on that year would go on to gross $1 BILLION. Tim Roth was almost cast as Severus Snape in the Harry Potter films. The part went to Alan Rickman.

Dana Delany Missed Out on SATC

Did you know that Sarah Jessica Parker wasn’t the only actress considered for the role of Carrie Bradshaw in SATC? Dana Delany’s decision is probably why you don’t hear much about her.

There’s no doubt that this move would have boosted her career, but she passed because she had worked on a few adult-themed movies before and did not want to do another show with the S-word on the title.

Denzel Washington Said No To Se7en

Denzel Washington regretted declining the role of Se7en after seeing a screening of the film. Washington was meant to play Investigator Mills, but Brad Pitt ended up playing him along with Morgan Freeman.

The reason why he turned it down was because the film was too “dark and evil.” Instead, he chose to do “Devil in a Blue Dress,” which was a box office flop, whereas Se7en was a hit.

David Schwimmer Turned Down MIB

Here’s an example of an actor we all know and adore who could have had a much bigger career if he had made a different decision. David Schwimmer declined the role of Agent J in Men in Black when he was offered it.

He was at the height of his career in 1996, with Friends being a smash hit, and he tried his luck with rom-com The Pallbearer, which flopped.

Anne Hathaway – Knocked Up

Katherine Heigl plays the part of Alison in the rom-com, Knock Up, along with Seth Rogan playing the male lead, but did you know that the part for Alison was originally meant for Anne Hathaway? You might or might not be able to imagine her in the place of the female leads.

Hathaway had her own reasons for not taking up the role; you might see why it was the best choice when you read more about it. She credited her lack of experience with her mother for not being the right person for the job.

Benicio Del Toro – Star Trek

Star Trek: Into The Darkness brought us Kahn, one of the most memorable villains in sci-fi movie history but played by the talented British actor Benedict Cumberbatch. The character had appeared in previous movies, but Into the Darkness was the most recent.

Initially, Benedict Cumberbatch was not in talks to play the role. Instead, it was meant for Benicio Del Toro. The Puerto Rican actor would later reject the role as they weren’t able to see eye to eye on the payment, and negotiations for the role weren’t enough to satisfy Del Toro.

Beyonce – Beauty And A Beast

Beyonce Knowles turned down the role of a character in Beauty and a Beast, but it might not be the character you were expecting. It wasn’t Belle, the main lead of the movie, played by Emma Watson, she would’ve been a bit old to play as Belle.

The part she was offered was for Plumette, the feather duster, and it might be easy to see why this role didn’t sit right with her. For such a big name as Beyonce, a smaller role wouldn’t suffice. Instead, Gugu Mbatha-Raw would play the feather duster.

Chiwetel Ejiofor – Spectre

Who doesn’t love a good James Bond movie, and who hasn’t dreamed about getting a chance to play a role in one of the many classical movies in the series? Well, apparently not Ejiofor, who was offered to play the role of the antagonist C in Spectre.

The star was offered a big paycheck but still refused the role of C, which might have been a big regret for him. Later, it was revealed through emails that the role would be passed on to Andrew Scott, who played the character for a lower sum.

Emma Roberts – Spring Breakers

It seems playing the role of Brit in the crime/drama movie Spring Breakers was not Emma Roberts’s cup of tea. She would have started with other Hollywood heartthrobs, including the Latin actors Vanessa Hudgens and Selena Gomez, and such a lineup of talented individuals would have surely been a force to be reckoned with.

The director revealed that his movies ‘go hard,’ which didn’t suit Emma Roberts really well, and creative differences also played a part. Emma Roberts rejecting the role led to Ashley Benson playing the part with some critical reviews.

Emma Stone – Ghost Busters

The new all-female cast of Ghostbuster was set to include someone you might not have expected to see in these types of movies. Emma Stone, who had been offered the role, had just finished starring in the Amazing Spider-Man series of movies, but it seemed like she was hesitant to take the following role.

According to her, the GhostBusters movies were an important franchise of films, and she was unprepared for such a big commitment at the time. In the end, she rejected the role, and the films gained favorable reviews.

Brad Pitt Almost Played Jason Bourne

There’s no doubt that Brad Pitt is a well-known actor. The movie actor has a long list of credits to his name, including roles in box office smashes. We know that his next decision didn’t completely destroy his career – far from it – but how much would it alter his Hollywood profile as we know it today?

In the hugely acclaimed Bourne series, Brad was intended to play Jason Bourne. While Pitt elected to feature in Spy Game instead, Matt Damon was cast as the titular agent. There are no bitter losers in this game, only a lot of what-if scenarios.

Gwyneth Paltrow – Titanic

The combination of Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet as Jack and Rose, the main couple of the movie, created one of the most romantic love stories on screen. Did you ever imagine how their chemistry might have played out if someone else played the role of Rose in Titanic?

When having a discussion with Howard Stern about her regretful rejections of movie roles, Titanic came up, and she revealed she had rejected the part for Rose. She said she couldn’t change the past, which means she might have been ready to accept the role later.

Jake Gyllenhaal – Suicide Squad

This might come across as a surprise to people who didn’t know that Rick Flag was supposed to be played by Jake Gyllenhaal. It had been previously dropped by Tom Hardy, and it seems like Gyllenhaal took the same path as the former.

Due to a number of scheduling conflicts, Jake had a ridiculously packed routine that left him with no time for Suicide Squad. We don’t know if he regrets not playing the character due to how successful Suicide Squad was, but the actor who played the character, in the end, did a pretty good job.

Ja Rule – 2 Fast 2 Furious

The Fast and the Furious franchise has become a staple for us viewers in what we expect from action movies, with each movie topping the other in ridiculous stunts. It wouldn’t be the same without the comedic genius of Tej Parker, played by Ludacris.

Ja Rule was expected to play the role initially, but after a role in the first movie, he grew a bit too arrogant in dealing with the creators of the franchise. It might not be hard to imagine how he regrets the rejection he made due to the success of the franchise.

Jennifer Hudson – Precious

This might have been the worst regret of Jennifer Hudson’s career as this was the movie that landed Gabourey Sidibe her Oscar Nominee. The role of precious was originally meant for Jennifer, but the singer rejected the role due to personal reasons.

She would later go on to reveal that she didn’t want to play a character where her weight was included as the main focus. She felt that where the character was supposed to go and how she was to be portrayed did not match her point of view, and she passed the role.

Jennifer Lawrence – The Hateful Eight

Quentin Tarantino had met with Jennifer Lawrence to discuss her potential involvement in the film “The Hateful Eight,” but it ultimately didn’t work out. Lawrence, who was busy with the publicity for “The Hunger Games” franchise and filming “Joy,” couldn’t commit to the project. Tarantino stated that Lawrence met with him as a courtesy, and he understood she was unavailable.

As a result, Jennifer Jason Leigh, 28 years her senior, was cast as Daisy Domergue and received her first Academy Award nomination for her performance. She may regret that Lawrence missed the opportunity to play the admirable role.

Kevin Hart – Tropic Thunder

Kevin Hart passed on the opportunity to play Alpa Chino, a closeted rapper, in the comedy film “Tropic Thunder.” In a 2015 interview with New York’s Power 105.1 radio station, Hart explained that he declined the role because he was uncomfortable playing a gay character.

He stated that the character’s actions in the script were too flagrant for him and that he didn’t think he could fully commit to the role due to his own insecurities. He regretted turning down the part, citing his respect for the film’s success and the opportunity it could have provided for his career.

Mark Wahlberg – Brokeback Mountain

Mark Wahlberg was offered the lead role in the critically acclaimed film “Brokeback Mountain.” Still, he turned it down after reading the script. According to Premiere magazine, Wahlberg was “a little creeped out” by the graphic and descriptive nature of the gay romance. He offered to discuss it further with the director, Ang Lee, but the opportunity passed.

The role went to Jake Gyllenhaal, who received an Academy Award nomination for his performance, and the late Heath Ledger, who won a posthumous Academy Award for his portrayal. Wahlberg has expressed regret for missing out on the excellent role.

Matthew McConaughey – Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2

In an interview with Playboy, Matthew McConaughey revealed that he turned down a significant role in the hit film “Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2” in favor of the Stephen King adaptation, “The Dark Tower.” He expressed concerns that the role in “Guardians of the Galaxy” was created merely to add another big-name actor to the cast. He didn’t want to be treated as an afterthought.

McConaughey didn’t disclose the specific part he was offered. Still, reports suggest that it could have been the role of Ego, portrayed by Kurt Russell in the film. McConaughey’s decision to decline the role may have been one he regrets, as the Marvel franchise continues to enjoy ongoing success.

Sarah Michelle Gellar – Clueless

Sarah Michelle Gellar was offered a role in the cult classic “Clueless.” Still, she had to turn it down due to her commitments to the soap opera “All My Children.” The co-producer of the movie, Adam Schroeder, was a fan of Gellar’s work on the show and recommended her for the part of Amber, the protagonist’s nemesis, Cher.

However, Gellar could not get out of her contract with “All My Children” for the two weeks necessary to film the movie, and she had to decline the role. Schroeder has since mentioned that he believes Gellar would have been perfect for the part, and Gellar herself has expressed regret over missing the opportunity.

Willow Smith – Annie

Willow Smith was initially intended to play the lead role in the 2014 “Annie” remake, which was produced by her father, Will Smith. However, Smith’s decision to decline the part was influenced by the difficulty she experienced while touring with her hit song “Whip My Hair.” In a speech at Temple University, Will Smith recounted his conversation with his daughter, where he attempted to persuade her to take the role by reminding her of the fun she would have in New York with her friends.

However, Smith declined and opted to be 12 years old instead simply. The role ultimately went to Quvenzhané Wallis, who received a Golden Globe nomination for her performance. Smith has expressed regret over missing the opportunity to play the classic character.

Zendaya – Aaliyah: The Princess of R&B

Zendaya was initially cast to play the role of Aaliyah in the Lifetime biopic, “Aaliyah: The Princess of R&B.” However, after facing backlash, the actress withdrew from the project. She explained in an Instagram video that her decision was not based on the negative reactions or criticisms but due to concerns about the production value, complications with music rights, and the delicate handling of the situation.

She also mentioned that she could not contact Aaliyah’s family, making her feel morally uncomfortable about taking on the role. Alexandra Shipp was eventually cast in the role. She succeeded in films such as “Straight Outta Compton” and “X-Men: Apocalypse.” Zendaya has expressed regret over passing on the huge role.

John Lithgow – Batman 1989

John Lithgow had the opportunity to play the popular comic book villain, The Joker, in Tim Burton’s 1989 film “Batman.” However, Lithgow revealed in a 2017 interview with Vulture that he declined the part during the audition process by attempting to convince Burton that he was not suited for the role.

Lithgow reportedly succeeded in persuading the director. The role ultimately went to Jack Nicholson, who received critical acclaim for his performance. Lithgow has expressed regret over turning down the opportunity to play such an over-the-top character.

Sean Connery – The Lord of the Rings

Sean Connery was initially offered the role of Gandalf in the hit film trilogy “The Lord of the Rings.” However, he turned down the opportunity, and the role eventually went to Ian McKellen.

The franchise achieved immense commercial and critical success, grossing over $2.91 billion in total box office sales. It is one of the few movies that Connery may regret not being a part of, given its overwhelming popularity and cultural significance.

Warren Beatty – Kill Bill: Vol. 1 and Vol. 2

Warren Beatty was initially set to play the role of Bill in Quentin Tarantino’s “Kill Bill: Vol. 1 and Vol. 2.” However, he ultimately turned down the part after learning about the intense filming schedule in China. As a result, the role went to David Carradine, who received critical acclaim for his performance.

Tarantino initially considered other actors, such as Bruce Willis, before settling on Carradine. Beatty regrets missing the opportunity to play such an excellent character in the acclaimed film series.

Sarah Jessica Parker – Beetlejuice

Sarah Jessica Parker was initially offered the role of Lydia in the 1988 Tim Burton film “Beetlejuice.” However, she turned down the part, which eventually went to Winona Ryder. Since then, Ryder has gained a reputation for her work in science fiction and fantasy projects, including her recent success in the hit Netflix series “Stranger Things.”

It’s unclear how much Parker regrets missing out on the opportunity to play such a dramatic character. Still, it’s interesting to imagine how her career may have changed if she had taken the role.

Jennifer Connelly – Pretty Woman

Jennifer Connelly was considered for the role of Vivian Ward in the 1990 romantic comedy “Pretty Woman.” However, the actress withdrew her name from consideration, feeling that she was too young for the part. The role eventually went to Julia Roberts, who received critical acclaim for her performance and cemented her place as a Hollywood superstar.

It’s unclear how much Connelly regrets turning down the opportunity to star in such a loveable film. Still, it’s interesting to imagine how her career may have differed if she had taken part.

Tom Cruise – Footloose

Tom Cruise was initially considered for the role of Ren in the 1984 dance drama “Footloose.” However, he had to turn down the part due to scheduling conflicts. He was already committed to another film, “All the Right Moves.”

The role eventually went to Kevin Bacon, who delivered a memorable performance and helped make the movie a cultural phenomenon. It’s unclear how much Cruise regrets missing out on the opportunity to star in such an iconic film. Still, it’s interesting to imagine how his career may have differed if he had taken part.

Emilia Clarke as Anastasia Steele (Fifty Shades of Grey)

Did you know that the fierce and fabulous Emilia Clarke, aka Mother of Dragons, was offered the role of Anastasia Steele in the steamy blockbuster Fifty Shades of Grey? Yep, you heard that right! But here’s the catch – Emilia turned it down! Can you believe it?

Fast forward a few years, and Emilia Clarke has admitted to regretting her decision. Can you imagine how different the movie would have been with the fiery Clarke in the leading role? We’re talking about a new level of sizzling chemistry and intense passion on the big screen.

Julia Roberts as Viola De Lesseps (Shakespeare in Love)

Did you know that the legendary Julia Roberts, aka America’s sweetheart, was offered the classical role of Viola De Lesseps in the award-winning hit movie Shakespeare in Love? But wait for it – she turned it down!

Fast forward to the present day, and Julia Roberts has come forward to admit that she regrets passing up the opportunity to star in the critically acclaimed movie. Can you imagine how different the story would have been with Roberts’ talent and charm on the big screen?

Albert Brooks as Harry Burns (When Harry Met Sally)

Did you know that the immensely talented Albert Brooks was offered the role of Harry Burns in the timeless romantic comedy When Harry Met Sally? Brooks declined the offer! Can you imagine what the movie would have been like with his wit and charm added to the mix?

But the plot thickens my friends – it turns out that Albert Brooks has publicly admitted to regretting his decision to turn down the role of Harry Burns. Imagine the comedic chemistry he would have had with Meg Ryan’s Sally! It’s almost too much to handle.

Reese Witherspoon as Sidney Prescott (Scream)

Did you know that the beloved Reese Witherspoon, aka Elle Woods, was actually offered the terrifying role of Sidney Prescott in the terrifying slasher movie Scream? That’s right – the queen of romantic comedies could have been the star of one of the most spine-chilling movies ever.

But here’s where things get really interesting. Reese Witherspoon ultimately turned down the role and later regretted her decision. Can you imagine how different Scream would have been with her trademark wit and charm? We can practically feel the goosebumps just thinking about it!

Tom Hanks as Jerry Maguire (Jerry Maguire)

Did you know that the legendary Tom Hanks, aka Forrest Gump, was offered the role of Jerry Maguire in the eponymous hit movie? That’s right – the man who played some of the most iconic roles in cinematic history could have been the star of one of the most beloved sports movies ever.

But here’s the kicker – Hanks turned down the role and later admitted to regretting his decision. Can you imagine how different Jerry Maguire would have been with his natural charisma and talent on the big screen? We can practically feel the sports fever already!

Leonardo DiCaprio as Dirk Diggler (Boogie Nights)

Did you know that the one and only Leonardo DiCaprio was offered the role of Dirk Diggler in the daring and provocative movie Boogie Nights? The man who made our hearts race in Titanic could have been the star of one of the most scandalous movies ever.

But wait, it gets even more fascinating. DiCaprio ultimately turned down the role and later admitted to regretting his decision. Can you imagine how different Boogie Nights would have been with his undeniable talent and star power on the big screen? We can practically hear the funky disco beats already!

Harrison Ford as Alan Grant (Jurassic Park)

Did you know that the legendary Harrison Ford, aka Indiana Jones, was actually offered the role of Alan Grant in the amazing dinosaur movie Jurassic Park? That’s right – the man who made archaeology cool could have been the star of one of the most groundbreaking movies of all time.

But here’s where things get really interesting. Ford turned down the role of Alan Grant and later admitted to regretting his decision. Can you imagine how different Jurassic Park would have been with his natural charisma and charm? We can practically hear the roar of the dinosaurs already!

Christopher Plummer as Gandalf (The Lord of the Rings)

Did you know that the great Christopher Plummer, known for his unforgettable roles in The Sound of Music and Knives Out, was actually offered the role of Gandalf in the epic movie trilogy The Lord of the Rings? The man who stole our hearts as Captain von Trapp could have been the star of one of the most beloved fantasy movies of all time.

Plummer turned down the role of Gandalf and later admitted to regretting his decision. Can you imagine how different The Lord of the Rings would have been with his commanding presence and gravitas? We can practically feel the magic in the air already!

Henry Winkler as Danny Zuko (Grease)

Did you know that the legendary Henry Winkler, aka The Fonz, was actually offered the role of Danny Zuko in the classic musical Grease? That’s right – the man who made leather jackets cool could have been the star of one of the most beloved movie musicals of all time.

But here’s the catch – Winkler turned down the role of Danny Zuko and later admitted to regretting his decision. Can you imagine how different Grease would have been with his natural charisma and cool factor? We can practically hear the sweet sounds of “Summer Nights” already!

Jake Gyllenhaal as Jake Sully (Avatar)

Did you know that the talented Jake Gyllenhaal was considered for Jake Sully’s role in the groundbreaking sci-fi movie Avatar? That’s right – the man who gave us unforgettable performances in Brokeback Mountain and Nightcrawler could have been the star of one of the most visually stunning movies of all time.

But here’s where things get really interesting – Gyllenhaal ultimately didn’t take on the role of Jake Sully and later admitted to regretting his decision. Can you imagine how different Avatar would have been with his natural intensity and depth? We can practically feel the magic of Pandora already!

John Travolta Passed On Being Forrest Gump

Imagine the Quentin Tarantino masterpiece Pulp Fiction without the charismatic presence of John Travolta as Vincent Vega. However, it came at the cost of him turning down the touching role of Forrest Gump.

While both movies pitted against each other at the 1995 Oscars, it was Forrest Gump who sprinted to the finish line, bagging six awards, including a Best Actor win for Tom Hanks. The dance floor of Pulp Fiction or a park bench with a box of chocolates? Travolta surely made a hard choice.

Burt Reynolds Skipped a Stroll with Pretty Woman

When you think of the 1990’s romantic-comedy Pretty Woman, the charming chemistry between Julia Roberts and Richard Gere is hard to overlook. But did you know the iconic role of Edward Lewis could have gone to Hollywood legend Burt Reynolds?

The star chose not to take up the opportunity, which also reminds us of the time when he said no to playing James Bond, doubting an American 007’s acceptance. In the end, it was Gere who walked the streets of Hollywood with Roberts.

Burt Reynolds Said No to the Force of Star Wars

In a galaxy far, far away, Burt Reynolds could have been the rogue smuggler Han Solo. Declining the role in George Lucas’s legendary Star Wars franchise, Reynolds confessed he didn’t want to tackle such a character at the time.

Even screen legend Al Pacino passed on the opportunity before it ultimately landed in Harrison Ford’s lap, transforming him into a Hollywood icon.

Leonardo DiCaprio, Brad Pitt, Matt Damon Didn’t Say Yes to Brokeback Mountain

Finding suitable actors for the challenging lead roles of Ennis Del Mar and Jack Twist in Brokeback Mountain proved to be an uphill battle. Some of the biggest names in Hollywood, including Leonardo DiCaprio, Brad Pitt, and Matt Damon, chose to skip the film.

It wasn’t until the reins were handed to director Ang Lee that Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal stepped into the shoes of these complex characters. Lee’s direction earned him an Oscar and Ledger a Best Actor nomination.

Mel Gibson Thought Gladiator Was Too Heavy a Burden

The Colosseum roared when Russell Crowe, as Maximus, boldly declared, ‘I will have my vengeance.’ But can you imagine Mel Gibson uttering these legendary words?

Gibson turned down Ridley Scott’s Gladiator, believing he was too old to endure the physicality of the role. But the universe had its plan, and it led the Kiwi actor Russell Crowe to the Colosseum, securing him the Best Actor Oscar in 2001.”